| Contract terms | Confirm the agreed steel grade, shape designation, quantity, length, tolerances, price basis, payment terms, and remedies for nonconforming material. | Written quotation, purchase order, technical specifications, and signed terms covering inspection, rejection, replacement, and dispute procedures. | Prefer a contract that identifies the governing specification and clearly assigns responsibility for freight, unloading, taxes, and claims. | 25% |
| Technical compliance | Check that the proposed W shapes, dimensions, and material grade match the project documents. ASTM A6/A6M covers general requirements for rolled structural steel shapes; ASTM A992 is commonly specified for structural steel shapes. | Mill test reports (MTRs) showing heat numbers, grade, chemical composition, and mechanical test results; dimensional inspection records where required. | Compare the offered product against the project’s exact specification and acceptance criteria. Do not substitute a grade or standard without written approval. | 20% |
| Delivery planning | Establish the ship date, delivery window, shipment method, delivery location, unloading requirements, and process for communicating delays. | Written lead-time confirmation, shipment schedule, freight terms, and a named contact for delivery updates. | Compare confirmed dates and the supplier’s ability to meet the project sequence. Lead times vary with stock, quantity, processing, and location, so verify them for each order. | 20% |
| After-sales support | Review how the supplier handles shortages, damage, documentation requests, technical questions, and material that fails agreed requirements. | Documented claims process, response contacts, return or replacement terms, and stated timelines for resolving issues. | Look for a clear escalation path and written responsibilities rather than relying on verbal assurances. | 15% |
| Traceability and inspection | Confirm that delivered pieces can be linked to their material documentation and that inspection requirements are understood before shipment. | MTRs, heat-number records, piece or bundle identification, packing lists, and inspection reports if specified by the contract. | Check that identifiers on the material and shipping documents are consistent. Specify any third-party inspection or hold points in advance. | 10% |
| Commercial and order flexibility | Compare quotation validity, minimum order quantities, payment milestones, cancellation terms, and charges for cutting or other processing. | Itemized quotation with material, processing, freight, and other charges shown separately where applicable. | Assess the total delivered cost and the consequences of quantity or schedule changes, not only the quoted price per unit. | 10% |