| Sample dimensional accuracy | Critical dimensions, datum relationships, hole positions, and fit features on trial parts. | All critical dimensions meet the drawing; non-critical dimensions meet their stated tolerances. | Ballooned inspection report, measurement results, and samples traceable to the production process. | Hold approval if a critical feature is out of tolerance or measurement methods are not identified. |
| Measurement capability | Whether gauges and measuring equipment are suitable for the feature and tolerance being checked. | Equipment is calibrated and appropriate; measurement repeatability is demonstrated for critical checks. | Calibration records, gauge list, measurement method, and repeatability study where risk warrants it. | Request a measurement-system review when results are inconsistent or close to specification limits. |
| Material and heat treatment | Material grade, hardness, heat-treatment condition, and other specified properties. | Results match the purchase specification and applicable material requirements. | Material test certificate, heat-treatment record, hardness results, and lot identification. | Do not release parts if material identity or required properties cannot be traced to the supplied lot. |
| Surface finish and coating | Specified roughness, coating type and thickness, corrosion protection, and visible defects. | Meets the drawing or specification; no defects that affect function, assembly, or service life. | Surface measurement results, coating inspection records, and visual samples under agreed lighting. | Clarify the inspection method and acceptance standard before approving appearance-sensitive parts. |
| Sample-to-process consistency | Whether approved samples were produced using the intended equipment, tooling, and process route. | The sample process is representative of routine production. | Process flow, machine or tool identification, setup records, and sample batch traceability. | Request a production trial if samples were specially made or the planned process has changed. |
| Audit: quality system | Document control, inspection planning, nonconformance handling, corrective action, and record retention. | Processes are documented, consistently followed, and supported by objective records. | Audit checklist, representative inspection records, corrective-action examples, and document revisions. | Require corrective actions for gaps that could affect product conformity or traceability. |
| Audit: production controls | Equipment maintenance, operator instructions, in-process checks, tool control, and change management. | Controls are defined for critical operations and changes are reviewed before implementation. | Maintenance logs, work instructions, process-monitoring records, and change-approval records. | Escalate uncontrolled process changes or repeated production issues before placing routine orders. |
| Traceability | Ability to connect finished parts to material lots, production dates, inspection records, and sub-processes. | Traceability meets the buyer’s specification and applicable regulatory requirements. | Example traveler, lot labels, inspection records, and a demonstrated traceability exercise. | Confirm that traceability can be maintained through subcontracted processes where applicable. |
| Delivery performance | Quoted lead time, capacity assumptions, order confirmation, and communication of schedule risks. | Commitments are realistic, clearly defined, and supported by a capacity or scheduling review. | Written quotation, production schedule example, capacity review, and escalation process. | Compare like-for-like lead times, including tooling, inspection, finishing, and shipping stages. |
| Final approval | Closure of sample findings, audit actions, specification questions, and commercial requirements. | Critical issues are closed; remaining actions have owners and agreed due dates. | Approved sample record, audit action log, final specification, and documented approval decision. | Approve conditionally only when open actions are low risk, documented, and monitored. |