| 1 | Define the Die and Part Envelope | Maximum die length, width, height, weight, clamping area, and access for loading and unloading. | Select a working envelope that exceeds the largest planned die by at least 10–20% in each critical direction. Confirm table load capacity with a safety margin. | Submit representative drawings and a completed die-weight list to the supplier. Request a dimensional fit check. | Restricted travel, unsafe loading, or the need for manual rework. |
| 2 | Evaluate the CNC Control System | Axis control, program storage, user interface, alarm history, parameter access, password levels, and data backup. | Prefer a multi-axis CNC system with readable diagnostics, protected parameters, program backup through standard industrial interfaces, and clear recovery procedures. | Run a sample program, review alarm screens, test data backup, and confirm operator access levels. | Longer troubleshooting time, program loss, and inconsistent operation between shifts. |
| 3 | Check Positioning and Welding Accuracy | Axis repeatability, positioning accuracy, torch or electrode alignment, fixture repeatability, and thermal distortion control. | Use the supplier’s stated accuracy only as a starting point. Require documented acceptance results under the intended load and welding cycle; repeatability should be suitable for the tightest feature on the die. | Conduct a witnessed test using a representative fixture and measure critical locations with calibrated inspection equipment. | Misaligned welds, dimensional variation, increased grinding, and rejected parts. |
| 4 | Assess Automation Level | Automatic loading, fixture clamping, seam tracking, torch height control, wire feeding, parameter selection, and part changeover. | Automate repetitive operations that directly affect consistency, while retaining manual access for setup, inspection, and maintenance. | Calculate cycle time for setup, welding, inspection, and changeover using actual production scenarios. | Higher labor content, operator-dependent quality, and lower equipment utilization. |
| 5 | Confirm Welding Process Compatibility | Supported welding process, material grades, thickness range, joint geometry, shielding gas, filler wire, and heat input requirements. | The machine must support the required current, voltage, duty cycle, torch configuration, wire diameter, and gas flow range for every planned material and joint type. | Run weld trials on production-grade material and inspect appearance, penetration, distortion, and mechanical or non-destructive test results where applicable. | Poor penetration, excessive spatter, porosity, distortion, or inability to qualify the process. |
| 6 | Review Fixture and Workholding Compatibility | Fixture mounting pattern, clamping force, datum strategy, quick-change capability, grounding, and access for the welding torch. | Use repeatable datums and positive location features. Ensure clamps do not obstruct torch travel or create heat-related movement. | Inspect the proposed fixture design in a 3D simulation or physical trial. Verify grounding resistance and clamp accessibility. | Part movement, weld obstruction, long setup times, and inconsistent dimensions. |
| 7 | Measure Throughput and Cycle Time | Arc-on time, indexing time, loading and unloading, parameter changes, inspection time, and planned maintenance. | Compare total cycle time rather than welding speed alone. Include realistic pauses, consumable changes, fixture changes, and operator handling. | Request a timed demonstration with representative dies and record the complete end-to-end cycle. | Capacity shortfalls, missed delivery targets, and inaccurate return-on-investment calculations. |
| 8 | Verify Safety and Fume-Control Provisions | Guarding, interlocks, emergency stops, light curtains or door switches, electrical protection, grounding, and welding-fume extraction. | The installation should comply with applicable local machinery, electrical, welding, and occupational-safety requirements. Fume extraction must be sized for the process and enclosure. | Review the risk assessment, safety circuit documentation, extraction airflow data, and commissioning test records. | Operator exposure, unplanned shutdowns, regulatory non-compliance, and accident risk. |
| 9 | Check Integration and Data Compatibility | Electrical supply, compressed air, shielding gas, network connection, production software, barcode or recipe management, and quality records. | Confirm voltage, frequency, power demand, air pressure, gas requirements, communication protocols, file formats, and available network interfaces before purchase. | Use an integration checklist and test representative program files, recipe retrieval, data export, and system alarms. | Installation delays, manual data entry, incompatible files, and weak production traceability. |
| 10 | Evaluate Serviceability and Total Cost of Ownership | Preventive-maintenance intervals, spare parts, consumables, calibration, remote support, training, warranty, and energy consumption. | Compare total ownership cost over the planned service life, not only the purchase price. Require maintenance schedules, critical-spare recommendations, training scope, and response commitments in writing. | Request a five-year cost model and inspect the service documentation, training plan, and spare-parts availability. | Unexpected downtime, expensive consumables, slow repairs, and higher lifetime operating cost. |